Homosexuality is still taboo in the Arab countries. While clerics denounce it as a heinous sin, newspapers, reluctant to address it directly, talk cryptically of 'shameful acts' and 'deviant behaviour'. Despite growing acceptance of sexual diversity in many parts of the world, attitudes in the Middle East have been hardening against it. In this absorbing account, "Guardian" journalist Brian Whitaker paints a disturbing picture of people who live secretive, often fearful lives; of sons beaten and ostracised by their families or sent to be 'cured' by psychiatrists; of men imprisoned and flogged for 'behaving like women'; of others who have been jailed simply for trying to find love on the Internet. Amid all the talk of reform in the Middle East, homosexuality is one issue that almost everyone in the region would prefer to ignore. Deeply informed and engagingly written, "Unspeakable Love" draws long overdue attention to this crucial subject.
BEIRUT: When Salim, a 20-year-old Egyptian, told his family that he
was gay, they packed him off for six months of psychiatric treatment.
When Ali, a teenager from Lebanon, was discovered to be gay, his
father broke a chair over his head and his brother threatened to kill
him for tarnishing the family honor. Ali left home and no longer has
any contact with his relatives.
When the family of another young Egyptian man found out their son was
gay, they beat him and then sent him to a therapist. He convinced a
young woman to pose as his girlfriend for a while, but once that ruse
was up, his family beat him again, this time so harshly that he fled
Egypt for the United States, where he applied for political asylum.
These are just a few among the many anecdotes that Brian Whitaker,
the Middle East editor for The Guardian newspaper in London, relates
in his new, groundbreaking book, "Unspeakable Love: Gay and Lesbian
Life in the Middle East."
Launched in Beirut on Wednesday night with a book signing at Zico
House and a party at Walima, "Unspeakable Love" explores the
experiences of young gay men and women in several countries
throughout the region, including Egypt, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia.
Whitaker filters their stories through the multiple lenses of social
norms, cultural expressions, the media, politics and religion.
To his credit, Whitaker does not shy away from but rather dives into
the murky questions surrounding homosexuality in the Middle East.
Is homosexuality a Western import and a sign of modernity's moral
decay? How does that square with the Orientalist fantasy of the
Middle East as a lush gay paradise? How do young people today
distinguish between homosexuality as a practice and homosexuality as
a self-proclaimed identity?
What are the various laws prohibiting homosexual behavior and how are
they implemented in various parts of the region? What are the
religious texts dealing with homosexuality, how have they been
interpreted and - perhaps most crucially - why have they been
interpreted as such?
And what, more basically, is the precise terminology at stake here in
Arabic, with such expressions as shaadh (pervert or deviant), al-mithliyya al-jinsiyaa (sexual sameness) and the latter's shorthand,
mithli and mithliyya, all in circulation at once?
Whitaker, 58, was motivated to write "Unspeakable Love" by the Queen
Boat incident in Egypt in 2001, when police raided a Nile River boat
that functioned as a floating nightclub and attracted a mainly male
clientele. Not only were numerous men arrested and jailed, but the
event was also one of the very few to bring issues of gay identity
and practice into the mainstream Arab media.
Three things become palpably clear from reading the book.
The first is that social attitudes are the single-most mind-crushing
factor for young men and women in Arab world who are trying to deal
with the fact that they are attracted to members of the same sex.
More so than legal statutes or religious edicts, the pressure to
marry is what pushes many of these young men and women to the
breaking point.
The second is that because not only homosexuality in particular but
sexuality in general remain so stubbornly taboo in the Middle East,
there is a dangerous dearth of reliable information, education and
counseling available for gay men, lesbian women and their respective
families.
Because sexuality is not discussed in the public domain, young people
lack even the actual vocabulary - the words, the terms, the turns of
phrase - to describe themselves and their actions in simultaneously
civic and sexual terms.
A city like Beirut may have a thriving gay subculture, and it may
even have a strong, impressive and unprecedented gay rights
organization in Helem. But homophobia remains rampant - even among
those who should know better - and homosexuality has yet to light the
imagination of any prominent politician. Imagine what it would take
to get gay marriage on the agenda of a Cabinet meeting or the current
national dialogue in Lebanon. Lots of red flags waving and
exclamation points popping there.
The third is that the push for gay rights in the region is very much
tied to wider issues of social and political reform. "It's not just about gay rights," says Whitaker. "It's about the
whole issue of reform, and reform is not just about elections."
True reform will have to take a full range of factors into
consideration, and "sexuality," he adds, "has to be a part of it." Whitaker has three ideal readers in mind - Westerners interested in
reform who need to look beyond voting structures, Arabs interested in
reform who need to get over outmoded leftist strategies and young
Arabs who are gay, ostracized and alone. For them, the book is
perhaps most important because even if the names have been changed
and the details have been deleted, it gives them a voice.
"I was basically trying to do a job of reporting, asking people about
their lives," Whitaker explains. "There's no book that deals with the
contemporary situation quite like this one." He lays a hand on the
cover and pats it once. "There are literary histories and
anthropological studies. But there are not books that talk to people
about their daily lives."
Whitaker admits that he could spend the rest of his career
researching the subject, but he says he would risk ending up being
just "that guy writing those books." In fact, he hopes he doesn't
ever have to write another book like "Unspeakable Love." In effect,
he hopes that by its publication, the book will break the taboo.
While it is entirely conceivable that "Unspeakable Love" could have
attracted the attention of a major publishing house in Europe or the
U.S., Whitaker chose to go with Saqi Books because of its foothold in
the region.
"This is where the issue matters," he explains.It was also important for him to launch the book in Beirut before
anywhere else. "I have been apprehensive about it being seen as
another Western attack." He says he recently turned down an interview
with CNN because he wanted to see how the local press would cover it
first.
All of which begs the question: Will "Unspeakable Love" be translated
to Arabic anytime soon? Speaking on the day before the launch,
Whitaker sounded hypothetically optimistic.
"Obviously, yes," he laughed. "It would be a major development, a
breakthrough, if it were to be translated to Arabic. I think the
situation with books is similar to the situation with the press.
People writing in the English language have a bit more freedom. I
hope people will read it in English and tell their friends about it
in Arabic. It's a pity it's not in Arabic, but it's a start."
By the time the launch rolled around on Wednesday, Whitaker's
publishers were adamant. "Yes," they said. "An Arabic translation is
in the works. It will be out by the end of the year." How's that for
progress?
Brian Whitaker's "Unspeakable Love: Gay and Lesbian Life in the
Middle East" is out now from Saqi Books. For more information, please
see www.saqibooks.com